The ultimate aim of any development project is to improve the
lives of people. It isn't always clear exactly how to do that. Our project
focused on developing the municipal government. Community development
would come through it. In 1995 the municipal government had no funds and
little credibility. Investments in an middle income pilot area helped to
reorient the city water and engineering departments toward well-planned
and executed public works. There was, however, no financial contribution
and little appreciation from that community. Still, the community has
generally made sure that the improvements were maintained.
Many useful things were learned from this pilot investment and applied
in follow-on activities such as the solid waste programme. The city
departments were mostly ready to undertake any development activities
responsibly, but municipal funds were non-existent.
In order to make an impression on the city as a whole, a lot of repairs
and improvements were needed, but the project had limited funds. A
programme of community co-financing was necessary, but there was no
precedent in Uttar Pradesh. How could it be done?
Community Co-financing
I walk to work through poor neighborhoods at the urban periphery and can
sense the conditions of the community and its potential largely through its
children. I am encouraged where children show spontaneous friendly behavior
because they represent the original nature of their parents before the burdens
of life overtook them. The first community that I found this way was Noorai ka
Bhattha. Although the children showed great human potential, there were many
fights among the adults over all manner of issues. Conditions were squalid and
people were unhealthy. Whoever had a tape player blasted his neighbors. Life
had little pleasure, except for the children playing in the open drain.
Noorai ka Bhattha Lane
In Noorai ka Bhattha (brick kiln) Lane an earthen ditch served as the main drain for the
community. In the middle of the footpath, this drain received kitchen water and,
since only 50
percent of the houses had toilets, dirty water also found its way to the open drain.
Half those
employed worked in the regional carpet industry.
Especially during the monsoon season, the unpaved street with the open drain proved
difficult for transporting the carpets up and down an incline to the houses where work is
carried out.
The community had been established for over 30 years at the edge of the built-up area of
the city, but had never been able to obtain basic urban services. Members
of the community were unhappy about the large numbers of mosquitoes and other pests
attracted to the open drain. They were ashamed at the appearance of the
community and the fact that few people were willing to pass through it because the open drain made it appear that it was an unsafe area!
I thought that such a community might want to improve itself and asked the
project community development specialist to try out the idea on the residents.
After a few meetings in 1997 a positive reply was given. From their meager resources the community offered to
contribute 20-30 percent of the cost of a drain construction.
However, before
work could begin, water supply to the few nearly closed connections abruptly
stopped. Then women and children were forced to walk long
distances to collect water from hand pumps where others were already waiting in lines.
This changed the situation completely and the community needed a hand pump
instead.
After making their contribution collection a new hand pump was promptly installed.
Soon after the community
collected money for a new street drain.
Almost all houses had extensions that blocked part of the footpath or open drains emptying
onto the footpath. During and after the drain construction, the community met informally
and as a panchayat, or village council, to remove these encroachments.

Drain construction took place during the monsoon season when there was a very real
chance that the mud-walled houses could collapse. Members of the community kept
watch through the night as the rains began. Several times the open ditch had to be
temporarily filled in to prevent the collapse of the houses. Yet, the community was
determined to make the sacrifice to take advantage of the opportunity to improve their
living conditions.

Community residents continued to improve their lane
with flagstones. and other improvements. Several families physically improved their homes and
two
small shops were opened. Less than one year after the installation of the hand pump and the new drain, the
community collected money to pave the mud foot path. When municipal staff does not clean the drain, male members of the community clean it themselves.
After all, it is their
drain, built with their hard-earned money!
The News Spreads
Every person in this community
knows many others in other communities and is a good advertisement who facilitates communication of news and ideas.
Since this programme went well in their community,
people in other communities got to know about it. This transmission and
understanding process takes time.
The next question was how to expand the programme. Since there
are many poor communities at the urban periphery these were a natural target.

After successful testing in several an additional objective was established that
as many communities of sanitation workers as possible be included. The reason
for this was to support the improvement in the solid waste programme by
improving home communities as well as work conditions.

New facilities such as hand pumps, street drains, etc. were a
priority, but it soon became clear that even simple assistance in repair of
existing facilities was greatly desired.

After a few of each type of work had been completed the time needed for
motivation and organisation decreased.
Soon the programme took on a life of its own. Council members as well
as independent community representatives would prepare a proposal to be
developed and managed through the normal municipal system once approved. The
only difference is that after initial approval the community must produce a bank
draft for the agreed 20-30 percent cost. Then work can begin and final payment
is made upon satisfactory completion.

Public response to the community financial participation
programme has been overwhelming and proposals exceed
current processing capacity. The initial goal was to include 20-30 percent of the
population.

By August 2000, or in a little over 3 years 318 works had been
completed in 200 communities with 70 families each. These 14,000 families
represent approximately 84,000 people or 40 percent of the population.

Community Awareness Programme
This is a tremendous achievement toward changing the attitude of the public
and their elected representative, both of whom are participating in the
programme. Such a large part of the public now can conceive of an alternative to
getting something for nothing.
To the extent possible follow up programmes have been conducted to further
support the improved outlook created from the community co-financing programme.
The main emphasis in these community awareness programmes has been on health and
hygeine and civics.

The awareness programme arranges for medical specialists, municipal officers
to introduce the community to quality of life issues and municipal services. An
introduction is also given to the use of the Mirzapur GIS for people, most of
whom have never seen a map before.

39 communities have been covered under the community awareness programme.
During the course of programme activities energetic and interested persons are
identified as urban volunteers to monitor continued activities in their
communities and in others.

And what of Noorai ka Bhattha after 3 years? Their leaders, children and city
council member have continued to play a strong role in community development.
Most recently they have been involved in promoting the door to door garbage can
programme in adjacent neighborhoods.

Noorai ka Bhattha has witnessed a tremendous growth since infrastructure
works were completed. The community has grown by more than 25 percent and is
hardly recognisable. It was recently visited by the World Bank Vice President,
Ms. Mieko Nishimizu.

Much work remains to be done. 161 communities need follow up through the
community awareness programme. Unfortunately, project funds have been cut by new
management. Still, the foundation that has been established has resulted in the
selection of Mirzapur as one of two Indian cities for UNICEF Healthy Cities
Project.
Back to Top of Page
Back to Home Page
|